Undercover police officer Mark Kennedy was ' engaged in activities that were much farther away than the authorization was given, the judges ruledThree senior judges has determined that the police officer disguised as Mark Kennedy illegally spied on environmentalists and arguably acted as an "agent provocateur".
In a judgment concerning explaining why they quashed the convictions of 20 climate change activists, the judges said they shared the "great public disquiet justifiable" on the case.
The judges, which included the lord chief justice, said "basic principles" of the process of fair trial were dropped when prosecutors did not disclose evidence about the Kennedy's work for lawyers of the activists.
The Court announced on Tuesday that he would crush the convictions of the activists, who were unjustly accused of conspiring to invade Ratcliffe on Soar central in 2009.
The sentence also made several criticisms of Kennedy, including that your deployment might have been interpreted as "trap". He revealed that Kennedy was part of a long-term programme "to infiltrate groups of the extreme left" in the United Kingdom. Other court documents say the Spy program was called operation Pegasus.
Kennedy, who expressed remorse for seven years lived deep under cover in the environmental movement, responded by saying in a statement issued by his publicist, Max Clifford: "I reject the claim that I acted as an agent provocateur. At no time did I or did I encourage actively a group or person to engage in an activity that were not already involved in. "
But now is for senior police officers explain why Kennedy, one of a network of police spies planted in protest groups, may have urged protesters to commit criminal acts, which were later prosecuted for.
Among those who will be asked questions is Sir Hugh Orde, President of the Association of Chief Police officers (Acpo), which was responsible for the grim unit that Kennedy was highlighted.
The unit of national public order intelligence was later transferred to the metropolitan police, under the command of Deputy Commissioner John Yates, who resigned this week.
Orde is being tipped as a Commissioner of the Met. So too is Bernard Hogan-Howe, the top-ranking officer conducting an official investigation on the case of Kennedy for her Majesty's Inspectorate of Constabulary.
ACPO said in a statement: "the law is quite clear that undercover officers are absolutely forbidden to induce people to commit offences otherwise they wouldn't commit. We are hopeful that the reviews for these events will make recommendations that will bring even more solid governance, accountability and management intrusive in undercover policing, preserving the value of the tactic to keep communities safe. "
All senior officials involved in the controversy will be alarmed at mounting evidence that Kennedy was "rogue", authentic sympathies for developing the cause defended by suspected extremists that he asked to monitor.
Known as Mark Stone for the activists who was sent to monitor – and UCO 133 for their police handlers – Kennedy put their concerns about their deployment in the registry.
"Middle class young people who are engaging with protest linked to climate change are not politicised, are worried about the future of the planet matters not politicians," he wrote a report to your handler.
Activists can be fun that he saw his cause as apolitical, but his interpretation of his reasons would, however, have assisted them in court.
So would be too recordings made secretly of activists when they gathered in a meeting before the planned protest.
A police raid that meeting by Nottinghamshire secured power station protest never occurred, and 113 people were arrested.
Of these, 26 were accused of plotting to invade the ease, but evidence of Kennedy, who also included a signed police statement in which he offered a measure of "support for the defense", was withheld from their lawyers.
As a result, the trial of six activists was abandoned in January. The convictions of the other 20 activists, found guilty in December, were judged on Tuesday for the same reason.
The judges left clear that Kennedy's surveillance tape would have supported the argument of the defendants at trial that he wanted to avoid further damage of the power station, carbon emissions.
"It is a case that gave rise to a great public disquiet justifiable, we share. Something went seriously wrong with the trial, "said the ruling. "Rights of indictment in relation to disclosure were not met. The result was that the appellants were convicted after a trial in which basic principles which underpin the impartiality of our evaluation procedures were ignored. The jury were ignorant of evidence useful to the defence, which was in possession of the accusation, but that has never been revealed. As a result Justice miscarried. "
The Crown Prosecution Service argued failure to disclose evidence of Kennedy are now the subject of an independent inquiry by Sir Christopher Rose, a retired Court of appeals judge.
But the judgment raises more questions about the operation to plant Kennedy and other agents of the secret police of the protest movement.
The undisclosed evidence files, the judges said, reveals Kennedy "was involved in activities that went far beyond that authorisation has been given and appeared to show him as an enthusiast of the occupation power station's proposal and, without doubt, an agent provocateur".
Doubts remain about its legal authority to spy on activists. Kennedy was not allowed to participate in the occupation power station until April 9, just three days before the planned protest.
Its surveillance of activists also exceeded his powers, according to the trial.
"When the protesters began to gather together just before the occupation proposal seems that Kennedy was much more than your authorization.
"Which included company recognition, information meetings, checking the surrounding area of policing and agreeing to participate in a team of climbers."
The judges agreed that Kennedy was arguably seen by younger activists as an "éminence grise" – influential decision-makers – within the group.
The ruling added that Kennedy played a significant role in assistance, advice and support ... the very activity for which the applicants were processed ".
This could be detrimental to the senior police responsible for the surveillance operation.
Vera Baird, the former Attorney-General, said: "it was a campaign of badly-thought-out to undermine people who turned out to be honest militants, criminals do not, during which they wasted a huge amount of money with this man who was inevitably native living with decent people for all those years.
"They then were left with it having let them down and with evidence that there was no crime in the first place".
没有评论:
发表评论